General Versus Thread

I think I'll go with one of the more famous ones: Perfect Cell (not Super) vs. Broly (the movie 8 version, not DBM's). You could even throw Bojack and Dabura in there, too.

Now, Broly ate a head-on Kamehameha wave without any ill effects.  (It may not have impressed him, but the same move from Goku sure blew Cell's mind.) Still, while Broly was able to withstand an awful lot of damage, he seemed to be having difficulty actually killing the Z-Fighters. If the Cell Juniors could beat up Vegeta, and Cell was stronger than them, and this was before he went to his max, I think Cell would've been able to hit a lot harder than Broly. If the two were to fight, I think they'd be about equal in speed and do about as much damage to each other, but Cell would eventually win through use of regeneration, I think.

Bojack is tricky, because (in the movie, not DBM) his base form was already apparently stronger than MSS Gohan, and who knows how much more his second form added on to that. I think he would have a better time against Cell than against Broly, since Cell is more fragile, but would ultimately be unable to beat either of them.

Movie 8 Broly would get wrecked by Super Saiyan 2 Gohan just as badly as the other two, though.

Though I don't want to begin a "Was Gohan Super Saiyan 2 against Dabura" debate right here (I'll make a thread for those sorts of things), I think Dabura was Perfect Cell vs. Vegeta level, so he'd get trounced by Cell, Broly, or Bojack in a straight fight, but if he could pull off his magical abilities the only one he'd lose against would be Cell (as seen in DBM). 

Other interesting matchups: Android 16 vs. Super Android 13, Metal Cooler vs. Bio-Broly

P.S. Android 13--the quote underneath your name is the reason why Funimation Dub is the best

What about transformed Janemba vs kid buu? In short, I think Janemba has the edge in raw power, but Buu would win due to his abilities. Also how do you think Hirudegarn would fare against these two? Or in an all-out brawl?

Not to mention if Kid Buu absorbed anyone with any level of intellect along the way and learned of the weakness to insults. XD

Broly vs Hatchiyak.

Actually the reason was that Hirudegarn was weak to emotions. Hence why the ocarina worked on him because it evoked emotions. He couldn't go into smoke form during those times. Goku was constantly acting like Vegeta and taunting Hirudegarn and then wuickly killed him with Dragon Fist. Also what if it was DBM Broly, Wheelo?

DBM Broly vs Hatchiyack- Broly destroys him because Salagir turned him into a freak of nature that can fight with Vegetto. That said, with Raichi there's potential for a DBM Hatchiyack to appear as his trump card, and there's freedom for him to be even stronger.

Tien vs Krillin- I'd go with Tien, and the reasoning is simply the reliability of their kill moves. The Kienzen is a really unreliable move, Krillin's kienzan has never scored a direct hit a single time in canon, it can be avoided fairly easily. Kikoho is a highly accurate attack that has actually never missed it's mark in the entirety of Dragon Ball, it was even good enough to intercept a ki-blast from Buutenks. In a match to the death there's a much higher chance of Krillin being tagged by the Kikoho than Tien getting tagged by the Kienzan. If this is post-Kami Saiyan saga versions then he's just straight up stronger as well.

17 vs 18- I always got the feeling these two were meant to be seen as equals. I guess I'd give a slight edge to 17, he seemed like more of a fighter and I believe he was the one bragging about how he was the strongest, which 18 didn't call him on. It could honestly probably go either way, I'd just personally give 17 with the benefit of the doubt.

17 vs 16- Android 16 would take 17 & 18 at the same time. He was more or less equal to Imperfect Cell, the same Imperfect Cell that had just crushed 17 and Piccolo and took their strongest attack without flinching.

Broly wouldn't be smart enough to do it, but any other Super Saiyan could probably beat Garlic Jr., Garlic wouldn't be able to harm a Super Saiyan, at all, I am not even sure he could throw them into the Dead Zone unless they straight up walked into it, and they would probably figure that throwing Garlic Jr. into the sun is the best solution.

Even if he can be completelly obliterated and still regenerate, the point stands that the sun could legitimately keep damaging his body as fast if not faster than he can regenerate, plus he would have to try to escape the sun's gravitational pull while severely damaged and weakened, it is worth to note that the sun(our real life sun, at least, I am not sure about DBverse's sun, but it is the closest estimative) has a gravitational pull 28x stronger than Earth, while Goku broke hit the 100G during the Namek saga, I am legitimately unsure if Garlic would be strong enough to get out while at full power, much less while being constantly damaged by the very thing he is trying to escape.

Eventually, when the sun died out and colapsed into a black hole(and I am talking several several millions years here), Garlic would be even more fucked, if he couldn't escape the sun, he would have no chance of escaping any natural black hole, even if he could escape, literal million years of isolation would have left his mind warped and broken, plus there is a very large chance that humanity perished long before that point(and it would definitely perish without the sun), so anything he ever knew would be gone.

As for Broly, if Broly couldn't figure out that throwing Garlic into a star is the best solution, Garlic could luck out and Broly would die of old age(I am not kidding here, it is the only way I can figure Garlic winning) before he could figure anything out, of course, there is a chance that Broly could fling Garlic into the sun or any other stars by complete accident, overall, if Broly tried to fling him out and missed, Garlic Jr. should know better than keep trying to to fight a Saiyan behemoth.

More likely Garlic Jr. would stupidly open up the Dead Zone like always and Broly would send him into it with a lariat.

GT Goku/Super 17 vs Buuhan- Have to give this to the GT cast, too much of a power boost from Z, it's implied that base Goku in GT is around the SSJ3 form of Z Goku. Elder Kaio actually states Baby Vegeta had the greatest ki he ever felt (which should include Buuhan and Vegetto) and SSJ4 Goku made a mockery of him. Super 17 may be a closer match initially, but he'd quickly shoot ahead if Buu used any ki-attacks on him, which it would likely come to.

Garlic Jr vs Broly: Depends on your interpretation of immortality. BoD's would have Broly win in the blink of an eye. If it's just pure not dying, then Garlic wins by Broly getting bored and leaving. Or Broly eats him. Eww.
Perfect Cell vs Broly: If it turns into a straight beam battle, Broly wins. If Cell displays some of the sneaky skill he exhibited in his imperfect form then he could beat Broly.
Android 16 vs. Super Android 13: If that was Super Piccolo then the two of them are roughly equal. 13 has a larger range of combat capabilities that would give him a very sharp edge, but 16 could win. He's analytical and his Hell Flash attack is a great ultimate. So I'd put it as 13 winning 6/10 times.
Metal Cooler vs. Bio-Broly: Cooler. Doesn't even need reasoning.
Kid Buu vs Janemba: Most of Janemba's attacks would do jack to Buu, and while we didn't see the limits of Janemba's endurance I doubt it's anywhere near Buu's. It either gets beaten to death or absorbed.
GT Goku vs Buuhan: Repeat of Vegito fight but with Buu dying.
Super 17 vs Buuhan: Absorption or candy ray win. Super 17 is cocky enough to just stand there and let the candy ray hit thinking its an average beam.
17 vs 18: 18. I know very little about moves she has that her brother doesn't, but if the common thing of her knowing the kienzan is true then that's a win.
DBM Broly vs Hatchiyak: Hatchiyak has to finish Broly quickly or its scrap.