??????
|
Post by Ashanark on Oct 5, 2016 22:14:05 GMT
I'm gonna have to disagree. It was a perfect chance to do something with Bra's character. Either take that chance and go with option E: Kold beats her down after a long, satisfying fight, or don't - and go with "A" and play it for laughs.In my humble opinion, as evidenced by the borderline hilarious scale and intensity of the outrage, "D" was, in the long run - the worst possible option to be taken, it didn't just piss off a single fraction of the fanbase, it managed to piss almost all of them off to varying degrees - it will leave a lasting stink. I've already seen it compared to the Bojack special and Future Gohan vs. Dabura, plenty of times. Whatever backlash a quick round of Koldstomping here or in the quarter-finals would cause, would be puny by comparison and would wash out the moment the next fight starts. Thanks for writing out a full response, explaining your opinion, and respecting mine! Now, the fight isn't technically decided yet, but... Here's the problem: As I see it, Bra (or Ginyu in her body) had to win, all along. Because the point of DBM is entertaining fights, and a curbstomp 4th-round fight won't be entertaining. So when Cold first whipped out his 6th form, I thought, "Oh, crap. People aren't going to be happy when he loses." A lot of us had thought Cold would lose, but also hoped it'd be a respectable loss, like Gotenks vs. Buu. But since Salagir gave Cold a chance we didn't know he'd have, Bra winning anyway was going to upset people. Maybe Salagir could've done that with somebody else, but not Bra. People didn't like her. I like Cold's 6th form--it really hyped up an otherwise straightforward fight. I also like the fight itself. Senzus, sword, gravity-goo--those don't bother me. What does bother me...I'll get to in a moment. Maybe I should try and explain better. Like you said, Bra sees everything in terms of strength; if you're "weak," you're a loser, and if you're "strong," she's okay with you. That's why I think Bra wouldn't learn from getting beaten by Cold, or even getting beaten by Gast: either way, losing still reinforces her "power = all" perspective. She'd think this is something she can solve with training, because that's always been how she deals with problems. Bra fighting Cold was strength vs. strength. There wasn't any "head-game." If Cold had attacked Bra mentally--"Remember, little wench--no Super Saiyan!" "Perhaps you just haven't trained hard enough!"--then I think she would've learned something. Heck, the best way for Bra to lose would've been her going Super Saiyan and getting disqualified. It would've hurt more than getting knocked out by Cold, because she would've realized she'd lost from not having self-control, just like Vegito and Gohan had been telling her all along. I think Bra'll only be humbled if she faces a problem where strength doesn't matter at all, or if she sees why strength might be bad. Gast could maybe do it, but I think it'll happen outside the tournament. This is what bothers me about the fight: I wish the chapter hadn't ended on a cliffhanger. Normally I don't mind those (like U13 Vegeta getting chopped), but this fight needed some closure. Does Bra win? Is Cold actually Ginyu, and he pulls off a switch? Does U16 chew Bra out for her behavior, or do they let it slide? Ending the chapter where it did--and then giving us a U16 special right after--gives us readers no idea of how we should interpret the fight, or what Salagir wants us to feel. If we saw Bra getting yelled at by Gohan, we could say, "Oh, okay, Salagir knows Bra was being a jerk. He knows that fight was unfair."
|
|
??????
|
Post by ltsarge on Oct 6, 2016 22:57:06 GMT
Who's been saying they want to see Bra raped? Not that I really care too much, cause creepers gonna creep, and some folks just say stuff like "Oh, you been raped" or make a TFS quote. But I really haven't seen the Bra rape pandemic in either forums. Do you have screen caps or links to pages? You must not follow DBM comment section that often as Bra at least gets a couple every time she fights or says something that isn't a stereotypical submissive waifu statement. The mods have gotten better at deleting those comments and banning those users but those users always find ways back. - Cold being Ginyu and pulling a swap in front of the entire audience would be poor writing and make Ginyu look incompetent than the serious threat he's being built up as. Not to mention that he wouldn't know how to act as Bra and that Bra isn't even the strongest. We also see the future vision of Bra and she isn't taken by Ginyu, she's still a daddy's girl she always has and looking down on those who dare to compare themselves to her father. No, I actually follow it every other day in the comments and read people's posts. I saw people cheering on bra getting brutalized by cold, but never saw any abundance of anyone saying they want to see her raped. I'm not even sure I've seen anyone say they want her to be raped once, and I've been a lurker on the dbm comments for a long time. If those guys as u claim are doing that, they are probably just trolls. Maybe the mods deleted those comments, or maybe they never existed, or maybe u have been exaggerating tremondously. but all I can say is provide proof or im just going to dismiss ur claim for now.
|
|
??????
|
Post by The Masterman on Oct 6, 2016 23:04:54 GMT
You must not follow DBM comment section that often as Bra at least gets a couple every time she fights or says something that isn't a stereotypical submissive waifu statement. The mods have gotten better at deleting those comments and banning those users but those users always find ways back. - Cold being Ginyu and pulling a swap in front of the entire audience would be poor writing and make Ginyu look incompetent than the serious threat he's being built up as. Not to mention that he wouldn't know how to act as Bra and that Bra isn't even the strongest. We also see the future vision of Bra and she isn't taken by Ginyu, she's still a daddy's girl she always has and looking down on those who dare to compare themselves to her father. No, I actually follow it every other day in the comments and read people's posts. I saw people cheering on bra getting brutalized by cold, but never saw any abundance of anyone saying they want to see her raped. I'm not even sure I've seen anyone say they want her to be raped once, and I've been a lurker on the dbm comments for a long time. If those guys as u claim are doing that, they are probably just trolls. Maybe the mods deleted those comments, or maybe they never existed, or maybe u have been exaggerating tremondously. but all I can say is provide proof or im just going to dismiss ur claim for now. I'm a lurker who never commented and I'm with you on this, I've never seen one rape comment in the year I've been lurking.
|
|
??????
|
Post by ltsarge on Oct 6, 2016 23:08:14 GMT
Not saying its impossible that someone could have said "I want to see Cold rape bra." This is the internet. And the mods have deleted some inflammatory comments in the past. I've just never seen it, and so when I hear it being a huge problem in the fan base I find that claim to be spurious at best.
|
|
??????
|
Post by Archon on Oct 7, 2016 0:59:35 GMT
While I did see one comment quite a while ago saying she needed to get raped (I think it was during the ki tennis in Cold fight) it was the only one and deleted shortly after I saw it.
|
|
??????
|
Post by Conqueror Geng on Oct 7, 2016 1:03:45 GMT
While I did see one comment quite a while ago saying she needed to get raped (I think it was during the ki tennis in Cold fight) it was the only one and deleted shortly after I saw it. I think it's safe to assume he's not on the forum (or maybe he was whatever ) so there's no reason to panick like he did. As evidenced by the poll, most people here don't hate Bra, nor love her. I'd say most don't dislike her by principle but are quite fed up with her bullshit, a somewhat unearned high power, and last episode. Most people likely have a long list of more preferable characters, but still don't "hate her". Considering all the recent exposure, and then this special... well, it's a bit of a Bra overdose, most are probably already a bit tired (despite the special is actually quite good).
|
|
??????
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 7, 2016 2:59:31 GMT
While I did see one comment quite a while ago saying she needed to get raped (I think it was during the ki tennis in Cold fight) it was the only one and deleted shortly after I saw it. I think it's safe to assume he's not on the forum (or maybe he was whatever ) so there's no reason to panick like he did. As evidenced by the poll, most people here don't hate Bra, nor love her. I'd say most don't dislike her by principle but are quite fed up with her bullshit, a somewhat unearned high power, and last episode. Most people likely have a long list of more preferable characters, but still don't "hate her". Considering all the recent exposure, and then this special... well, it's a bit of a Bra overdose, most are probably already a bit tired (despite the special is actually quite good). I'd also like to point out aside from the 'overdose' you mentioned, it also doesn't help that: 1. The page she beat Cold in seemingly glorified the moment as well, what with being full HD and all. Yes, I understand why they did this, releasing the page early by accident, but still, it rubbed people the wrong way. 2. The current chapter is going at a much slower pace than usual. Of course I understand this, they have to do it, they don't have a choice unless they just go on hiatus for a few months, but to a lot of people it's making this special much more drawn out.
It's really just horrendous timing :/
|
|
??????
|
Post by Ashanark on Oct 7, 2016 3:45:58 GMT
2. The current chapter is going at a much slower pace than usual. Of course I understand this, they have to do it, they don't have a choice unless they just go on hiatus for a few months, but to a lot of people it's making this special much more drawn out.
It's really just horrendous timing :/ Yeah. Considering how controversial of a fight this was, and also where the chapter ended--Bra chopping Cold, but not being declared winner--having a 3 month wait before we see what happens next...isn't going to make people happy.
|
|
??????
|
Post by Archon on Oct 13, 2016 3:21:23 GMT
The problem is it was a recurring theme for him to say stuff like that even outside the forums. So I doubt it's a joke. Either way this is off topic so....yeah. So this guy is actually Bartek...? Or...? By the way, moved this discussion to banned thread. He goes by 'Whatever' in the comments section as well so I doubt it.
|
|
??????
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 13, 2016 12:50:41 GMT
Personally, since the Mary Sue bs became a thing, I haven't noticed many comments mentioning rape, however, aaaaages ago I recall it being very common. In fact, the reason I stopped being a lurker was to tell cunts to shut the fuck up about their unjustified levels of hatred for Bra as it was preventing me from enjoying the comment section. It was fucking ridiculous. Just think about this, replace the short single sentenced comments that negatively mention Mary Sue these days with I want her to die and/or get raped comments, that's how it used to be before the mods were forced into action.
Now they have this grossly misused buzzword Mary Sue to work with and can't get banned for saying it and this is beginning to fry me all over again. I would love for the comments section to get a word filter.
|
|
??????
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 13, 2016 20:24:26 GMT
Personally, since the Mary Sue bs became a thing, I haven't noticed many comments mentioning rape, however, aaaaages ago I recall it being very common. In fact, the reason I stopped being a lurker was to tell cunts to shut the fuck up about their unjustified levels of hatred for Bra as it was preventing me from enjoying the comment section. It was fucking ridiculous. Just think about this, replace the short single sentenced comments that negatively mention Mary Sue these days with I want her to die and/or get raped comments, that's how it used to be before the mods were forced into action. Now they have this grossly misused buzzword Mary Sue to work with and can't get banned for saying it and this is beginning to fry me all over again. I would love for the comments section to get a word filter. First off, anyone genuinely wanting to see a fictional character get raped has a screw loose somewhere.
Anyway, the way I hear it there is a word filter; when you comment something with the word "first" within the first 20 to 30 or so comments (not sure really lol, that's just a guess) you aren't allowed to post the entirety of your comment without removing the word(s) "first" (however many there are) or waiting it out. This has happened to me a few times. Apparently it is to put a stop to people who apparently think they're on YouTube from spamming "First" in the comments when a new page comes out.
|
|
??????
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 15, 2016 19:06:27 GMT
I didn't mind Bra all that much until this recent match. I'm still hoping for a potential double KO ! At the last second, King Cold swings what's left of his tail and severely injuries Bra then they both collapse and pass out at the same time. It's somewhat of a win-win situation because Bra learns to not underestimate her opponents when she thinks they're down and King Cold gets spared from having to face off against the mighty Gast next round. If not a double KO, then at least a major scolding from Gohan or Vegetto. It works with the placement of this recent special because it revealed more of her relationship with Gohan and he seems to be one of the few people she'll listen to.
|
|
??????
|
Post by Son Pan on Oct 15, 2016 23:27:52 GMT
I prefer the scolding from option. I think the more reasonable fans were upset at how the fight was presented more than the actual outcome. I don't think Bra being eliminated alongside Cold in a double knock out would really solve anything and just cause more backlash. Vegetto getting eliminated through XXI trick was one thing, but Bra being eliminated by a tail whip would cause her fans to explode, which in turn would cause her haters to lash right back. It's smarter to cut our loses here and hope the next match up is presented better.
|
|
??????
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 15, 2016 23:45:01 GMT
I prefer the scolding from option. I think the more reasonable fans were upset at how the fight was presented more than the actual outcome. I don't think Bra being eliminated alongside Cold in a double knock out would really solve anything and just cause more backlash. Vegetto getting eliminated through XXI trick was one thing, but Bra being eliminated by a tail whip would cause her fans to explode, which in turn would cause her haters to lash right back. It's smarter to cut our loses here and hope the next match up is presented better. Exactly! I wouldn't have cared that she won if it had been done better. Instead, she was given odd techniques (particularly those incapacitating ice clones or whatever it was she used) and overall it didn't make much sense. Personally, I would have liked it better if she had been forced to transform (putting him in the state he was in Bardock's vision) but still winning because their "deal" was not acknowledged by officials.
Besides, I agree, at this point I don't think Cold has much control over his tail or even his body in general. Bra sliced through a good chunk of it.
|
|
??????
|
Post by Son Pan on Oct 15, 2016 23:54:49 GMT
I prefer the scolding from option. I think the more reasonable fans were upset at how the fight was presented more than the actual outcome. I don't think Bra being eliminated alongside Cold in a double knock out would really solve anything and just cause more backlash. Vegetto getting eliminated through XXI trick was one thing, but Bra being eliminated by a tail whip would cause her fans to explode, which in turn would cause her haters to lash right back. It's smarter to cut our loses here and hope the next match up is presented better. Exactly! I wouldn't have cared that she won if it had been done better. Instead, she was given odd techniques (particularly those incapacitating ice clones or whatever it was she used) and overall it didn't make much sense. Personally, I would have liked it better if she had been forced to transform (putting him in the state he was in Bardock's vision) but still winning because their "deal" was not acknowledged by officials.
Besides, I agree, at this point I don't think Cold has much control over his tail or even his body in general. Bra sliced through a good chunk of it.
Overall it was just wasted potential. The two extra forms added to Cold caused enough of a stir by themselves, but them being wasted (at what point did having four arms even come into play?) that we might as well have just had another quick joke match and moved on from there.
|
|
??????
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 16, 2016 0:03:04 GMT
Exactly! I wouldn't have cared that she won if it had been done better. Instead, she was given odd techniques (particularly those incapacitating ice clones or whatever it was she used) and overall it didn't make much sense. Personally, I would have liked it better if she had been forced to transform (putting him in the state he was in Bardock's vision) but still winning because their "deal" was not acknowledged by officials.
Besides, I agree, at this point I don't think Cold has much control over his tail or even his body in general. Bra sliced through a good chunk of it.
Overall it was just wasted potential. The two extra forms added to Cold caused enough of a stir by themselves, but them being wasted (at what point did having four arms even come into play?) that we might as well have just had another quick joke match and moved on from there. Yeah, that was another gripe I had with how the match was done. They came into play during their Ki blast tennis but he still lost. I get that he was bigger and Bra was maneuvering more (air advantage) but he was just as fast and had double the arms. I think his extra arms should have made up for his lack of movement but they didn't, and at the end of the day there was no point in giving them to him.
If it had been presented as a joke match, I would have been happy with that as well. However, that clearly wasn't the case given how she was on the brink of death and about to be brutally killed by Cold. I guess we can kind of take the beginning of the match (Ki blast tennis) as a joke or comic relief, but it didn't give off that vibe to me.
|
|
??????
|
Post by Son Pan on Oct 16, 2016 0:38:26 GMT
I said this in another thread so I just decided to copy and pasted on how I would have liked the fight to have gone down. I would change the Bra and Cold fight as well. I would still have Bra win and get rid of the senzu bean as well, but I would have added more to this fight. More emphasis should have been put into the close range combat. I would keep the ki blasts reflection match, but I wouldn't allow Cold to take so much damage from it and I would have used that as a opportunity to justify the four arms by showing Bra struggle trying to keep up with Cold (not the other way around). This when I would have introduced her different techniques here. It shows Bra has learned different techniques from the Z-fighters or other people (similar to Goku), to show she is not all power. I probably wouldn't have done the clone trap thing exactly, but maybe Bra having an explosive double based on Tien's multiform and Gotenks Ghost Kamikaze. Gradually Cold would start using his techniques to counter, to show off Cold is more deadly than Freeza and Cooler. For funs its revealed Cold learned Instant Transmission (and how to sense ki) like Metal Cooler did.
Bra would get in more desperate straits and overwhelmed by Cold as the fight goes on. She is on the losing end of the fight, getting wrecked pretty bad, but she manages to use solar flare to blind Cold than use her ki blade to cut him in half to win. Bra still wins through skills and tactics, while still realizing she barely won the fight and she seriously underestimated Cold. It is a lesson of humility for her, but she still remains in the tournament and shows us she is a skilled warrior who overcame her opponent through skill and technique (which I don't think the chapter did a well enough job at).
I also think Bra turning down the bet to show she doesn't conform to the common Saiyan weakness of love of battle beyond reason would have worked fine as well. It shows Bra is smarter than we think. If she cited she was no longer fighting for herself, but U19 it would show is more noble than we think or she is at least a jerk with a heart of gold. It can have her trash talk Cold about how useless his family is and how he can only hope to win is by her not fighting at full power and point out the remaining competitors wouldn't agree to those terms either. Sure some might be annoyed by Bra, but it would be a genuine moment of awesomeness for her as well.
|
|
??????
|
Post by mbg on Oct 17, 2016 2:57:12 GMT
I said this in another thread so I just decided to copy and pasted on how I would have liked the fight to have gone down. I also think Bra turning down the bet to show she doesn't conform to the common Saiyan weakness of love of battle beyond reason would have worked fine as well. It shows Bra is smarter than we think. If she cited she was no longer fighting for herself, but U19 it would show is more noble than we think or she is at least a jerk with a heart of gold. It can have her trash talk Cold about how useless his family is and how he can only hope to win is by her not fighting at full power and point out the remaining competitors wouldn't agree to those terms either. Sure some might be annoyed by Bra, but it would be a genuine moment of awesomeness for her as well. These are all pretty good ideas. I think another way to go about it would be to have Cold be the one relying on outside methods to level the playing field. Like, what if he sent an agent over to poison Bra's food? Or what if Buu gave him knowledge of some kind of ki-draining attack? The biggest problem with the fight, IMHO, is that Cold is the underdog in the situation. He's gone further than any other member of his race, by far - even Cooler, whose whole gimmick is being "the serious one who actually bothered to train," didn't know about a second augmentation form. Bra's trained too, sure, but it's hard to take that seriously when she could have squashed Cold as a first-grader. And when a character's the underdog who worked hard for what they've got, the audience immediately roots for them a little. Salagir tries to circumvent this by making Cold stronger than Base Bra in terms of brute power, but it rings hollow because the only reason Bra's having any trouble is because she's an idiot. Instead of making Form 2 Cold stronger than Bra, Salagir could have had Cold be the same strength or slightly weaker, and have him rely on cruel or cheating methods to get the upper hand. Then Bra would go further and further into her own strength to try to kill him, eventually being forced to admit that brute force is really all she's got. This would reveal a weakness in Bra's character - she's spent so long relying on her inborn strength that her skill with tactics or dealing with unconventional opponents has atrophied. She could have to deal with the humiliation of being nearly killed by an opponent less than a percentage point of her strength. Instead, Salagir tries to push a message that Bra is both a great sheer-power fighter and a great unconventional and tactical fighter, but it doesn't work. Partly because Bra's previous character flaw has been "I must learn to control this unfathomable power" (killing Zangya, for instance), and partly because none of those new abilities were given any kind of foreshadowing. It doesn't make Bra seem clever, because part of making a character clever is showing them make the best of what they've got. It's why chess is so often associated with intellect, because it's a completely fair game with defined rules and resources, so when a character beats an opponent at chess, you know they were genuinely better at using their resources than their opponent. "Outsmarting" an opponent by using a never-revealed power is like a chess player "beating" an opponent by revealing that their pawns can actually move like queens. It even makes Bra's already questionable conduct in earlier fights look even worse, because if she really could snare opponents so easily, why didn't she just use that technique on Zangya and Eleim? It feels like it was trying to answer complaints about Bra not having earned her power, but it was done in a very clunky fashion that honestly just makes her look even worse. Instead of letting the flaw stand and have it inconvenience her, he tries to correct it, but the problem is that he corrects it in a way that is neither convincing nor congruent with Bra's prior character. We're already past the half-way point of the story, considering that nothing was done with the character up to his point(all exposition, but no development) and that by the time she, once gain takes the centre stage, we're probably gonna be at around 70% mark, whatever shift she'll potentially experience will either be laughably " snap-of-finger" sudden(because there won't be any time left for an interesting 'journey'), or won't happen at all. Salagir probably has some sort of plan, but I have no idea what it is. This is my other big problem with a lot of people who claim that it's not the time for Bra to go through development. We are twelve hundred pages in, and talking about one of the most prominent characters in the comic... and she's still basically the same person she was in Comic #1. She's had backstory revealed since then, but that's not the same as character growth. And she's not like Goku or Vegeta, where she has an entire franchise of development backing her; she's mostly an OC. And as an OC, we're partly interested in Bra because we want to know her story - and if Bra's story is "Bra beat up people who were way weaker than her anyway," then Bra's story is incredibly boring. Hell, even Bra's development in her backstory is kind of lacking. Look at Gast's specials, where he goes through a clear arc from a guy who cared only about reviving his race to going out of his way to protect and live with others - meanwhile, Kid Bra seems to be basically the same as Older Bra only marginally more bloodthirsty (and even then, that's only if you ignore Novelization Bra) and significantly more whiny.
|
|
??????
|
Post by Xeno Black on Oct 18, 2016 6:20:14 GMT
Personally I originally found Son Bra to be a annoying prick with a whole lot of power to back up her incessant bolstering. But due to her fight against King Cold (and how Asura draws her), I seem to have slightly soften up to her despite my initial resentment towards her. Of course she is still a brat that acts worse than Vegeta ever has (in terms of personality, not by actual crimes since Vegeta is knees deep in sin from his past), but she has potential to become something great if she invests in growing in a healthy, positive direction.
For example, if Bra finally decides to follow Gohan and her father's former fusee-self (Goku) mindset, she could become a badass (even though she already one) that can actually fight threats responsibly without jeopardizing everything she wants to protect. Instead of using a kamehameha haphazardly as a SSJ2 due to a persistent enemy, her son-like mindset may instill in her to fight as a SSJ and use unique technique or strategy to win the day, with zero casualties. However, if she remains the same as she is in the tournament to adulthood, I fear she will become a great threat to her universe, thus proving Moori's greatest fears all those years ago when talking to Vegetto on New Namek. Only time will tell I suppose.
|
|
??????
|
Post by scottyrogers on Oct 30, 2016 18:32:38 GMT
When looking at just her character, U16 Bra's fine. A lot of people don't seem realize that she's not the same as U18 Bra; she's the daughter of Vegetto, so it makes sense for her to be so strong and have crazy potential. People also complain about her being arrogant and cocky, but plenty of characters are like that in this series. Vegeta acted like an arrogant jackass throughout DBZ and not many people complained, but when Bra acts like one, there's a problem? Please. I will admit that her fight with Cold is terribly written, though; her having Senzus was such an asspull.
The problem with Bra is that she's a fan-character, and like all of Salagir's fan-characters that are competing in the tournament, they're unnecessary to Multiverse. The main appeal of Multiverse was to just see the characters that had already existed in Dragon Ball fight each other. To see the hypothetical fights that are constantly debated in the fanbase. Nobody wanted to see fan-characters.
|
|